Zip-locs, poop bags, and squicks

Photo of Americans being sent to concentration camps
https://anchoreditions.com/blog/dorothea-lange-censored-photographs

We reuse zip-loc bags for picking up dog poop in the backyard, so they go from holding a sandwich to, well, being a poop bag. We also buy poop bags for picking up poop on dog walks. It doesn’t bother me to put a zip-loc bag or box of them on the counter—at least not until it’s been used for poop. But I get a squick if an unused bag sold as a poop bag—never used, remember, so physically no different from a zip-loc—is on the counter.

I’m bringing this up in order to make two points. The first is that my reaction is irrational, but that doesn’t necessarily make it bad or something I have to change.The second is that recognizing that I have a squick can help me respond more reasonably to something (a squick) that is by definition unreasonable. The Urban Dictionary defines “squick” as:

“1. Noun. The physical sense of repulsion upon encountering a concept or situation one finds disgusting.
2. Noun. A situation or concept which engenders this reaction.
3. Verb, transitive. To cause someone to have this reaction.
4. Verb, intransitive. To experience this reaction.

The concept of the “squick” differs from the concept of “disgust” in that “squick” refers purely to the physical sensation of repulsion, and does not imply a moral component.

Stating that something is “disgusting” implies a judgement that it is bad or wrong. Stating that something “squicks you” is merely an observation of your reaction to it, but does not imply a judgement that such a thing is universally wrong.
” (emphasis added)

One of many bad consequences of the fallacious rational/irrational split is that people who believe in it believe that being “rational” (they often have a muddled definition of “rational”) is always good, and being “irrational” is always bad. So, you should not allow yourself to have “irrational” beliefs.

But we all have squicks—someone might get a squick if their peas touch their mashed potatoes, I don’t want poop bags on my kitchen counter, some people don’t want used poop bags in their trash bins.

If we believe that we aren’t allowed to have squicks, then we start inventing reasons that they’re rational. It’s common for neighborhood mailing lists to blow up over the issue of putting dog poop bags in someone else’s trash bin. That’s a squick, but people will go to great lengths to try to pretend it’s rational. My favorite was someone saying they were trying to be considerate of the garbage collectors, but the dog poop is going to go into someone’s trash, so the garbage collector is still dealing with bins that have bagged dog poop, as well as used kitty litter, diapers, and all sorts of things much more gross than dog poop in a plastic bag. If it’s a squick for you, then it’s fine to ask that people not put dog poop bags in your bin. It’s reasonable for people to respect your squick not because your squick is reasonable, but becaue it’s reasonable to be a considerate neighbor. Squicks can be respected.

But sometimes they shouldn’t be. In an earlier post, I mentioned the way that we can conflate our feelings about someone or something with the very nature of that person or thing—we project our feelings about them onto their identity. So, for instance, if I feel threatened by something you say, I might conclude that you are a threat. Maybe you are, but maybe it’s just a squick on my part about people who have hair like yours. If you put a box of unused dog poop on your counter, and I am disgusted, it would be unreasonable for me to conclude that you are disgusting.

George Orwell, in his under-read and under-appreciated The Lion and the Unicorn, has a useful discussion of emotions like hate and fear (27-28):

“If you hate and fear Russia,if you are jealous of the weal and power of America, if you despise Jews, if you have a sentiment of inferiority towards the British ruling class, you cannot get rid of those feelings simply by taking thought. But you can at least recognise that you have them, and prevent them from contaminating your mental processes.”

I’ve written elsewhere about how important that was process was for the race-based mass imprisonment of Japanese Americans—racism, demagoguery, propaganda, and anxiety meant that too many people took their own feelings about Japanese-Americans as facts about Japanese-Americans’ identities. Earl Warren’s irrational advocacy of race-based mass imprisonment was the consequence of his fear of Japan. Given the bombing of Pearl Harbor it was reasonable to fear Japan; it was unreasonable to extend that fear to all people of Japanese ethnicity. But he tried to pretend to himself and others that his reaction was the consequence of a rational assessment of behavior and risk. It wasn’t.